Check your trimpots to make sure they are the correct values at each location, and the values of resistors everywhere (measure them, and compare against the good board).
When you adjust the DC offset with VR4 (a little at a time), also check what happens to the voltages across R11, R13 (and R12, R14). One should increase and the other should decrease, but how much are they varying by?
If this doesn't help to pinpoint a problem, then check all your voltages against the β24 (class AB) operating points PDF and see if there is anything grossly out of whack.






